yei mÅ«á¸ha kahe, — jÄ«va Ä«Å›vara haya 'sama'
seita 'pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«' haya, daṇá¸e tÄre yama

 yei mÅ«á¸ha - any foolish person who; kahe - says; jÄ«va - the living entity; Ä«Å›vara - the supreme controller; haya - are; sama - equal; seita - he; pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« haya - is a first-class atheist; daṇá¸e - punishes; tÄre - him; yama - the superintendent of death, YamarÄja.


Text

“A foolish person who says that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the same as the living entity is an atheist, and he becomes subject to punishment by the superintendent of death, YamarÄja.

Purport

ÅšrÄ«la BhaktisiddhÄnta SarasvatÄ« ṬhÄkura says that the word pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« refers to one who considers the living entity under the control of the illusory energy to be equal with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is transcendental to all material qualities. Another kind of pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« is one who does not believe in the spirit soul, the superior potency of the Lord, and therefore does not distinguish between spirit and matter. While describing one of the offenses against chanting the holy names, specifically the offense called Å›ruti-Å›Ästra-nindana (blaspheming the Vedic literature), JÄ«va GosvÄmÄ« states in his Bhakti-sandarbha, yathÄ pÄá¹£aṇda-mÄrgeṇa dattÄtreyará¹£abha-devopÄsakÄnÄá¹ pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«nÄm. “Worshipers of impersonalists like DattÄtreya are also pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«s.†Concerning the offense of ahaá¹-mama-buddhi, or dehÄtma-buddhi (considering the body to be the self), JÄ«va GosvÄmÄ« states, deva-draviṇÄdi-nimittaka-‘pÄá¹£aṇá¸a’-Å›abdena ca daÅ›ÄparÄdhÄ eva laká¹£yante, pÄá¹£aṇá¸a-mayatvÄt teá¹£Äm: “Those who are overly absorbed in the conception of the body and the bodily necessities are also called pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«s.†Elsewhere in the Bhakti-sandarbha it is stated:

uddiÅ›ya devatÄ eva juhoti ca dadÄti ca
sa pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«ti vijñeyaḥ svatantro vÄpi karmasu

“A pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« is one who considers the demigods and the Supreme Personality of Godhead to be one; therefore a pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« worships any kind of demigod as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.†One who disobeys the orders of the spiritual master is also considered a pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«. The word pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« has been described in many places in ÅšrÄ«mad-BhÄgavatam, including 4.2.28, 30 and 32, 5.6.9, and 12.2.13 and 3.43.

On the whole, a pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä« is a nondevotee who does not accept the Vedic conclusions. In the Hari-bhakti-vilÄsa (1.117) there is a verse quoted from the Padma PurÄṇa describing the pÄá¹£aṇá¸Ä«. ÅšrÄ« Caitanya MahÄprabhu quotes this verse as the following text.